CUBE café|bar Book Club

This month we reviewed 'Winter Ghosts' presented by Kate Mosse and
'The Narrow Road to the Deep North' by Richard Flanagan


It was great to be back in the discussion at this February’s book club and to see some new faces. I don’t know about you, but I had a great night, so thank you for your hilarious input. Welcome to Sally and Ruth who were first timers.

February books were: The Winter Ghosts by Kate Mosse  and The Narrow Road to the Deep North by Richard Flanagan

The Winter Ghost got slated! Thanks for that suggestion Claire. It did generate a brilliant discussion; May and Essam listened to the audio book version which was especially depressing. Essam described the narrator as sounding close to tears for the majority of the novel. He persisted with the book because he thought there would be a twist or a surprise. There wasn’t! 3/10

May described it as “very depressing rubbish” 3/10

Sue described it as “predictable and full of literary clichés, with no characterisation” 2/10

Helen thought it was far-fetched and airy fairy, at times a bit wishy washy. It should have stayed as a 50-page novel as the rest of the content was pointless.

Fiona wanted to slap her! She found it frustrating from start to finish “it felt egocentric, had inaccuracies, it lacked depth, was good on location but was mainly fluffy rubbish” 5/10

Susan was the only one that had anything positive to say about the book.  “It was a wiz of a read, the first half of the book was a masterclass in descriptive writing ( although quite often pointlessly)”.  Susan added that the author’s description of a family’s loss of a relative, without having a body to mourn, was also extremely thought provoking and moving. 5/10

The consensus was that the novel should have stayed as a short story as 50 pages would have been more than enough.

CUBE Book Club Average Rating: 3/10

The Narrow Road to the Deep North by Richard Flanagan had the opposite effect on the group. This book was crammed with content, twists and turns, drama, sorrow and a love story.

Ruth thought it was beautifully written with great description. Some of the content made uncomfortable reading, “the description of the camps was a bit much and adultery as a topic is uninteresting to me”. One negative for Ruth was the lack of quotation marks, but the book was a great read. Ruth also spoke about a scene that has stayed with her: an officer who, like everyone, was starving sacrificed himself giving up a steak for his men. 8/10

There was a lot of discussion about the author’s reasons for writing this book; his dad had been in a Japanese POW camp and, although it isn’t a true story, it is believed that a lot of the narrative, and some of the characters, are based on the author’s own experience. A harrowing thought but it gives you a greater respect for the story.

Fiona said it was “an amazing book, moving and emotional. The characterisation of the men in the book and their interaction was brilliant.” Fiona felt the book fell down when it came to the relationship with the wife as it didn’t feel as realistic” 9/10

Helen told us the book was set during the Second World War and was about loss and near misses. She thought the author had to write this for his dad. “It was well plotted with good twists”  9.5/10

Definitely worth a read!

CUBE Average Book Club: 9/10

A couple of books of interest came up during the chat. ‘The View from Castle Rock’ by Alice Munro and ‘Le Grand Meaulnes’ by Alain Fournier (perfect French Sally!) also known as ‘The Lost Estate’. Just in case, you want to suggest them for book club or read them on the side.

Next month we are meeting on 28th March and discussing the following books:

The Sealwoman’s Gift by Sally Magnusson
and/or
This Is Going to Hurt by Adam Kay

See you then!

Catherine Ward,
CUBE café|bar Manager

Categories

Tags

Illuminos  Hertiage Lottery Fund  student  Planning  veganism, acro, nikki&jd, dance, Déda, Derby  India Festival  john mcdonald  Joli Vyann   An Evening with the Siddiquis   variety  comedy  Stopgap  celebration  mindfulness   Meditation  Lost Dog  Cha Cha  Midlands  apprentice  education  Emma  Lydia Atkinson   Nikki and JD  learning  Back pain  Blog  National Youth Circus Event  Dance Together Live Better  art  Acrobatics   Jump  Juliet and Romeo  feedback  Dance Active  cabaret  Déda Board  Derby Festé  T42 Residency  Déda  Derby Theatre  Features  Projects   Students  QUAD  Discusssion  Wendy  Website Design  START  dyslexia  Youth dance circus  Déda Refurb  Schools  Hydra  Poetry Performance  Print  STEAM   Postural Stability Instruction   artcore,   Clare Brooksbank  artist  actor  jive  NCCA  Plymouth  Déda Theatre  books  Building work  Wellbeing  Celebrate  placement  Fundraising   Clare Limb  Acro   Path  Residences   young people  class   dance for dementia  volunteer, Deda, dance, arts, Derby, Derbyshire, marketing, 20 years  wedding  December   Dance4  Sky Academy  visual art  Productions    Community  vlog  Outdoor Performance  University of Derby  Stress  Website  Ben Spiller  Waltz  Just Imagine Working Here  story  Photography  Udancebythesea  Artists  reading  business  Charity  siteline  Yoga  Salsa  Jasmin Vardimon  Danni Chell   Deda  #dancetogetherlivebetter  Developer  Studio  event  Marilyn Monroe  professional  Candoco  retro  regular  Derbyshire   Performace  Michaela Butter  meeting  National Centre for Circus Arts  storytelling  DJ  Udance  Déda Bloggers  Exercise  ArtCore  carnival  Performances  flamenco express  PSI   Tour  Circ Bizerk  hula hoop  office  ballet,   Leah   Unviersity of Derby  Website Development  birds  Knot  mythology  Ballet  marketing  celebrating age  expansion  Dance Development  salsa,   Updates  mood,  fun  Coordinator  SNOW  Hercules  older people  Routine  Circa Tsuica  News  Vale  disco  choreography  City centre  Audience  Danish+  research  vintage  funding  commercial  relaxed performance  group  performance  Heritage  BA Dance  Christmas  Anima   Rock 'n' Roll  Children and young people  projection  Highlights  Brochure  Theatre  Stephen Munn  Participation  party  Degree  Youth  Derby  words  disability   outreach   refurbishment  Music  Ballroom & Latin  facilities  Fifties  Arts  acting  New Year's Resolutions   Victoria Brown   Poet  anxiety,   Web Developer  dance, placement  Bounceback  Déda,   development  Stompers  Workshops  Regional  Derby Book Festival  Tender  Graphic Design  CUBE  Simon Armitage  Circus  Performers  drawing  Book Club  Soul  interview  lor bird  diversity  DYDC  Contemporary Dance  Derby,  Plus One  New Dimensions  AGM  Social  hubbub  Jodie  Goals  Greek  Journalism  Vlogs  Strictly  New Year  NCCA  The Siddiquis   Blogs  work experience  Dance Development and Learning  depression,   Festivals  hardy group  Night at the Theatre,  Culture  partner  Dancing,   Inspiring  dance, dancers, Joss Arnott, Derby, Déda, Triple Bill   National Lottery  Northern Soul  Competition  Poetry  50s  social isolation  dance,   ACE Dance and Music   Arts Award  Perfom  Hen Party  Ashtanga  Rolls-Royce  dementia  Outdoor Events  U.Dance  Shows  volunteer  BSL interpreted  free  update  socialise  network  family  review  Alice Vale  InCompany  Adaire To Dance  Creativity  student, work experience   inclusive  Derby University  Summer  social dancing,   Kathak  digital  Foxtrot  Casson and Friends  University  management  contemporary  RnB  Dance Career  New Year New You   training  Southbank  Career  disabled  history  Classes  Sleep  health,   STEM   sara brighty  BBC  ACE Midlands  Autumn  dancer  New Website  Graphic Designer  September  corporate  Aakash  offer  accessible  study  Course  food  Derby Dancing | Déda | Derby Dance | Dance | Heritage Lottery Fund | HLF | HeritageLotteryFund | Rendezvous de Dance | Victor Sylvester | Stork Club | Italian Club | Polish Club | Locarno | Locarno's | New Penny | Blue Orchid | Bell Hotel | The Clouds |   isolation,   Higher Education  ballroom  Nightclub  Baby Shower  Studying  Fitness  accessibility  Dancing  café  Cultural Vision  Hires  2019  social media  Choice  Zumba  Fresher  Children and the Arts  Writing  All Dance  BA Hons Journalism,   club  East Midlands  flamenco   Arts Council  Tutor  New Art Club  Icarus  Creative Living,   Holly Noble Company   Chellaston Academy  photo  Shakespeare  FORMAT  Derby Arts  Dance  Relaxation